Compare
Taskly vs Thumbtack.
A directory where professionals pay for customer leads, set their own lead prices and quote you separately for the work. Taskly is an open marketplace for the Greater Toronto Area: you describe a task, Taskers send fixed-price offers, and the payment is held until the job is done.
Every claim about Thumbtack below is taken from their own published pages and links to the page it came from. Last checked October 1, 2026. Where they publish nothing, the row says Not verified rather than guessing.
At a glance
The two models, row by row
Each row names what is being compared and answers it for both platforms. A row marked “Not verified” means Thumbtack does not publish it on the pages we read — not that the answer is no.
Marketplace model
What kind of platform is it?
Taskly
An open marketplace: you describe the task, Taskers make offers on it
Thumbtack
Customers describe a job; professionals pay for the lead and respond
Thumbtack Help — paying for leadsMatching
How are the two sides brought together?
Taskly
Your posted task is shown to Taskers who work in that category
Thumbtack
Two kinds of lead: matched leads a pro pays for automatically, and "Opportunities" where the pro reaches out first
Thumbtack Help — paying for leadsChoosing who does it
Who picks, and on what?
Taskly
You choose from the offers you receive, each with a price attached
Thumbtack
You receive responses from pros who chose to pay for your job, and pick from them
Thumbtack Help — paying for leadsPricing structure
Hourly, fixed, quoted or set rate?
Taskly
A fixed price per task, agreed before the work starts
Thumbtack
Pros set their own lead prices, and a higher price makes them more competitive for those leads
Thumbtack Help — setting lead pricesWhat the customer pays the platform
Any fee on top of the work?
Taskly
A platform fee shown on the payment screen before you pay
Thumbtack
The pages read describe what pros pay, not a customer-side platform fee.
What the worker pays the platform
Commission, lead fee or subscription?
Taskly
A commission on a completed job. Taskers never pay to see or answer a task
Thumbtack
Pros pay per lead. For a matched lead the fee applies automatically; for an Opportunity the pro "only pay[s] the price shown if the customer responds"
Thumbtack Help — paying for leadsPayment handling
Who holds the money, and when does it move?
Taskly
Taskly holds the payment and releases it to the Tasker once the job is confirmed done
Thumbtack
The pages read do not describe Thumbtack holding payment for the work itself.
If something goes wrong
What recourse is published?
Taskly
A dispute is raised on Taskly and the held funds stay frozen while it is reviewed
Thumbtack
No protection or dispute mechanism was found on the pages read.
What you can get done
How broad is the catalogue?
Taskly
131 categories, from household work to lessons, events and digital tasks
Thumbtack
Local services across many trades
Thumbtack for professionalsWhere it operates
Which markets, and how relevant to the GTA?
Taskly
The Greater Toronto Area
Thumbtack
Canadian coverage is not stated on the pages read.
| What is being compared | Taskly | Thumbtack |
|---|---|---|
| Marketplace modelWhat kind of platform is it? | An open marketplace: you describe the task, Taskers make offers on it | Customers describe a job; professionals pay for the lead and respond Thumbtack Help — paying for leads |
| MatchingHow are the two sides brought together? | Your posted task is shown to Taskers who work in that category | Two kinds of lead: matched leads a pro pays for automatically, and "Opportunities" where the pro reaches out first Thumbtack Help — paying for leads |
| Choosing who does itWho picks, and on what? | You choose from the offers you receive, each with a price attached | You receive responses from pros who chose to pay for your job, and pick from them Thumbtack Help — paying for leads |
| Pricing structureHourly, fixed, quoted or set rate? | A fixed price per task, agreed before the work starts | Pros set their own lead prices, and a higher price makes them more competitive for those leads Thumbtack Help — setting lead prices |
| What the customer pays the platformAny fee on top of the work? | A platform fee shown on the payment screen before you pay | Not verified The pages read describe what pros pay, not a customer-side platform fee. |
| What the worker pays the platformCommission, lead fee or subscription? | A commission on a completed job. Taskers never pay to see or answer a task | Pros pay per lead. For a matched lead the fee applies automatically; for an Opportunity the pro "only pay[s] the price shown if the customer responds" Thumbtack Help — paying for leads |
| Payment handlingWho holds the money, and when does it move? | Taskly holds the payment and releases it to the Tasker once the job is confirmed done | Not verified The pages read do not describe Thumbtack holding payment for the work itself. |
| If something goes wrongWhat recourse is published? | A dispute is raised on Taskly and the held funds stay frozen while it is reviewed | Not verified No protection or dispute mechanism was found on the pages read. |
| What you can get doneHow broad is the catalogue? | 131 categories, from household work to lessons, events and digital tasks | Local services across many trades Thumbtack for professionals |
| Where it operatesWhich markets, and how relevant to the GTA? | The Greater Toronto Area | Not verified Canadian coverage is not stated on the pages read. |
Workflow
What actually happens, start to finish
The same job, run through each platform.
Taskly
- 1Describe the task in your own words — type it, say it, or send a photo.
- 2Taskers who work in that category see it and send offers, each with a fixed price.
- 3You pick an offer. The payment is held by Taskly, not sent to the Tasker.
- 4The Tasker does the job and you confirm it is done.
- 5Taskly releases the payment, and the two of you can review each other.
Thumbtack
- 1Describe the job you need done.
- 2Professionals pay a lead price to reach you — automatically for a matched lead, or only if you reply to an Opportunity.
- 3You hear from the pros who chose to pay, and pick one.
- 4Price and payment for the work itself are arranged with that pro.(not verified)
Money
How the price is set, and who pays the platform
Two separate questions, and the platforms answer them differently.
Pricing structure
Hourly, fixed, quoted or set rate?
Taskly
A fixed price per task, agreed before the work starts
Thumbtack
Pros set their own lead prices, and a higher price makes them more competitive for those leads
Thumbtack Help — setting lead pricesWhat the customer pays the platform
Any fee on top of the work?
Taskly
A platform fee shown on the payment screen before you pay
Thumbtack
The pages read describe what pros pay, not a customer-side platform fee.
What the worker pays the platform
Commission, lead fee or subscription?
Taskly
A commission on a completed job. Taskers never pay to see or answer a task
Thumbtack
Pros pay per lead. For a matched lead the fee applies automatically; for an Opportunity the pro "only pay[s] the price shown if the customer responds"
Thumbtack Help — paying for leads| What is being compared | Taskly | Thumbtack |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing structureHourly, fixed, quoted or set rate? | A fixed price per task, agreed before the work starts | Pros set their own lead prices, and a higher price makes them more competitive for those leads Thumbtack Help — setting lead prices |
| What the customer pays the platformAny fee on top of the work? | A platform fee shown on the payment screen before you pay | Not verified The pages read describe what pros pay, not a customer-side platform fee. |
| What the worker pays the platformCommission, lead fee or subscription? | A commission on a completed job. Taskers never pay to see or answer a task | Pros pay per lead. For a matched lead the fee applies automatically; for an Opportunity the pro "only pay[s] the price shown if the customer responds" Thumbtack Help — paying for leads |
Payment
Who holds the money, and what happens if it goes wrong
Only what each platform documents. A blank here would be the most misleading thing on the page, so an unverified mechanism is labelled as one.
Payment handling
Who holds the money, and when does it move?
Taskly
Taskly holds the payment and releases it to the Tasker once the job is confirmed done
Thumbtack
The pages read do not describe Thumbtack holding payment for the work itself.
If something goes wrong
What recourse is published?
Taskly
A dispute is raised on Taskly and the held funds stay frozen while it is reviewed
Thumbtack
No protection or dispute mechanism was found on the pages read.
| What is being compared | Taskly | Thumbtack |
|---|---|---|
| Payment handlingWho holds the money, and when does it move? | Taskly holds the payment and releases it to the Tasker once the job is confirmed done | Not verified The pages read do not describe Thumbtack holding payment for the work itself. |
| If something goes wrongWhat recourse is published? | A dispute is raised on Taskly and the held funds stay frozen while it is reviewed | Not verified No protection or dispute mechanism was found on the pages read. |
Trust
What each platform says it checks
Quoted, not summarised. Different platforms check different things and describe them in their own words; none of this should be read as a guarantee about an individual.
| What is being compared | Taskly | Thumbtack |
|---|
Coverage
Where the work happens
Taskly is a Greater Toronto Area marketplace. Coverage is the dimension most likely to change, so it carries the check date above.
What you can get done
How broad is the catalogue?
Taskly
131 categories, from household work to lessons, events and digital tasks
Thumbtack
Local services across many trades
Thumbtack for professionalsWhere it operates
Which markets, and how relevant to the GTA?
Taskly
The Greater Toronto Area
Thumbtack
Canadian coverage is not stated on the pages read.
| What is being compared | Taskly | Thumbtack |
|---|---|---|
| What you can get doneHow broad is the catalogue? | 131 categories, from household work to lessons, events and digital tasks | Local services across many trades Thumbtack for professionals |
| Where it operatesWhich markets, and how relevant to the GTA? | The Greater Toronto Area | Not verified Canadian coverage is not stated on the pages read. |
Situations
Which one fits what you are trying to do
Not a verdict — a description of what each platform is shaped for, drawn from the rows above.
You want several quotes to compare
You care how the worker is charged
You want the money held until the job is done
Taskly
What Taskly's model actually is
Described directly, without reference to anyone else.
You describe the task, not a service code
The price is fixed before anyone starts
Taskly holds the payment
Taskers pay only when they are paid
Questions
Questions people ask about Taskly and Thumbtack
Answered from the sourced rows above. No FAQ markup — that rich result was retired, and the answers are the point.
Do professionals pay for leads on Thumbtack?
Yes. Thumbtack’s help pages describe pros paying per lead and setting their own lead prices. There are two kinds: matched leads, paid for automatically, and Opportunities, where the pro only pays the price shown if the customer responds.
Is there a membership fee on Thumbtack?
Thumbtack states there is no charge to join, no annual fees and no membership fees. The cost to a pro is the leads themselves, controlled by the lead price they set and a weekly budget.
Who holds the money?
On Taskly, Taskly does — the payment is held and released once the job is confirmed done. The Thumbtack pages we read describe how pros pay for leads, not a platform holding payment for the work, so we list that as not verified rather than assuming either way.
What does it cost a worker to answer a job?
On Thumbtack, the lead price the pro has set. On Taskly, nothing: a Tasker can read a task and make an offer at no cost, and Taskly takes a commission only when a job is completed and paid.
Sources
Where these facts came from
Each is a page published by Thumbtack, read on the date shown. Platforms change their terms; check the source before relying on a figure.
- Thumbtack for professionalsread October 1, 2026
- Thumbtack Help — paying for leadsread October 1, 2026
- Thumbtack Help — setting lead pricesread October 1, 2026
Taskly’s own rows describe shipped behaviour and were checked on the same date. Taskly makes no insurance, background-check or guarantee claim about any Tasker.
Next
Where to go from here
Also compared: Taskly vs TaskRabbit · Taskly vs Jiffy · Taskly vs Kijiji